Car Rental and Ride Hailing: Which Option is Best for You in Singapore?

Car Rental and Ride Hailing - Which Option is Best for You in Singapore?

Ever found yourself frustrated while waiting for a ride-hailing driver during peak hours, only to see the fares surge through the roof? Or maybe you’ve considered renting a car but worried about the hassle? In a fast-paced city like Singapore, getting around efficiently is key, and both car rental and ride hailing have their own perks and downsides. But which one is truly the better option for you? Let’s break it down.

1. Cost – Which Option is More Wallet-Friendly?

When it comes to affordability between car rental and ride hailing, it really depends on how often you need a car. If you’re someone who only needs transport occasionally, ride hailing can be a cost-effective choice since you pay only when you need a ride. However, frequent users might start feeling the pinch, especially with unpredictable surge pricing during peak hours or bad weather.

On the other hand, car rental in Singapore offers fixed daily, weekly, or monthly rates, which can be more economical for those who drive regularly. While you do have to consider fuel costs, having a rental car eliminates unpredictable fare hikes. Plus, with fuel-efficient hybrid and electric rentals becoming more common, you can save even more in the long run.

2. Convenience – The Freedom of Having a Car vs. Waiting for a Ride

One of the biggest advantages of short-term car rental is the sheer convenience of having a car at your disposal 24/7. No more waiting around for a driver, no last-minute cancellations, and no need to stress over whether a ride will be available when you need it most. You’re in complete control of your schedule, whether it’s a spontaneous supper run or an urgent trip to the office.

On the flip side, if you prefer to sit back and let someone else handle the driving, this might be the better choice. However, the downside is dealing with inconsistent driver availability, especially during peak hours, weekends, or special events when wait times can be frustratingly long.

3. Flexibility – Short-Term Convenience vs. Full Control

If you only need a car once in a while and don’t want the long-term commitment, ride hailing is a clear winner. It provides quick, on-demand transport without worrying about insurance, maintenance, or other responsibilities.

However, if you value the ability to drive wherever and whenever you want,daily, weekly or monthly car rental is the way to go. Whether you need to make multiple stops, pick up friends or family, or take an impromptu road trip to Malaysia (without the worry of VEP), a rental car gives you the flexibility to do it all—without the per-ride costs adding up.

4. Practicality for Different Situations – Which Option Works Best?

  • Daily Commutes: If you have a predictable work schedule, car rental may be a more practical and cost-effective choice, especially if public transport isn’t convenient for your route.
  • Family Trips: Need to shuttle kids around or pack heavy luggage for a weekend getaway? Having a weekly car rental is far more convenient than booking multiple ride-hailing trips. Enjoy the flexibility of choosing an MPV or SUV that offers ample cargo space for your luggage and a smooth, comfortable ride.
  • Special Events & Late-Night Rides: Getting a ride-hailing service after a concert or festive event can be a nightmare with surge pricing and long wait times. A rental car lets you skip the hassle.

If you’re a light traveller who prefers not to deal with parking, or fuel top-ups, ride-hailing is the way to go. But if you value reliability, cost stability, and the freedom to drive on your own terms, renting a car might be the smarter choice – especially for frequent drivers or those who need a vehicle for more than just the occasional trip. 

Ultimately, choosing between car rental and ride-hailing boils down to your lifestyle and travel needs. Whichever you choose, be it car rental and ride-hailing, make sure it fits your budget, convenience, and comfort!

If you’ve decided that car rental is the right fit for you, we’ve got a fantastic selection of vehicles waiting. Experience the ultimate convenience with myCarriage, no deposit required, and a wide range of vehicles from MPVs to cabriolets to choose from. To make your experience even smoother, we settle the VEP for your trips to Malaysia, and offer the option to add Touch ‘n Go or FlashPay cards. It’s the complete package for all your needs. 

We have conveniently located outlets at Pandan Gardens, Alexandra, and Changi Airport, making it easy for you to find one near you. Or if you prefer, we offer the convenience of having your car delivered and collected directly to you. Book your ride today. Enjoy the freedom to drive on your own terms!

If you love the ride, you have the option to lease it through our comprehensive long-term car lease services, tailored to fit your needs.

Are You Ready

to embark on amazing journeys and memorable experiences with myCarriage?